CBSE Class 9 English Beehive Chapter 20: If I Were You NCERT Solutions
This section offers comprehensive NCERT Solutions for CBSE Class 9 English Beehive, Chapter 20, 'If I Were You'. It addresses questions focused on understanding the play's narrative, the characters' driving forces, and its central themes. Students will analyze the dramatic irony present, the intruder's flawed scheme, and Gerrard's ingenious response. The solutions explore the subtleties within the dialogue, the dynamics between characters, and the play's inherent tension. Designed to illuminate challenging parts of the text, these solutions assist students in comprehending the story's complexities and the playwright's techniques. They serve as a vital tool for exam readiness, providing lucid explanations and perspectives on the chapter's material, ultimately strengthening comprehension and sharpening analytical abilities for future assessments.
Quick info
| Board | CBSE |
|---|---|
| Class | Class 9 |
| Subject | English Beehive |
| Session | 2026 |
| Language | English |
| Type | NCERT Solutions |
| Chapter | Chapter 20 |
Chapter summary
Chapter 20 of the CBSE Class 9 English Beehive textbook, 'If I Were You', is explored through these NCERT Solutions. The solutions focus on analyzing the dramatic encounter between Gerrard and an intruder. Key aspects covered include understanding character dialogues, identifying the motivations behind the intruder's actions, and evaluating Gerrard's wit and resourcefulness in a dangerous situation. The exercises also touch upon language usage, specifically distinguishing between commonly confused words, thereby aiding in vocabulary and comprehension development.
Learning outcomes
- Understand the plot and character dynamics in 'If I Were You'.
- Analyze the motivations and intentions of the intruder and Gerrard.
- Interpret the meaning and significance of key dialogues.
- Identify and explain instances of dramatic irony and suspense.
- Differentiate between commonly confused words and use them correctly in context.
Topics covered
Paper topics
- Character Analysis: Gerrard and the Intruder
- Plot Comprehension
- Dialogue Interpretation
- Dramatic Irony
- Suspense and Thriller Elements
- Character Motivation
- Gerrard's Cleverness
- Intruder's Desperation
- Vocabulary Building
- Distinguishing Homophones
- Play Analysis
- Thematic Exploration
Important topics
- Understanding Gerrard's strategy
- Analyzing the Intruder's motives
- Interpreting key dialogues
- Identifying plot twists
- Vocabulary: Commonly confused words
PDF preview
Read page by page below. PDF is streamed from the official NCERT website — no download button on this page.
Questions and Solutions
Question 1
(i) The line is spoken by Gerrard.
(ii) Gerrard says this because the intruder has just entered his house and is interrogating him. The intruder forces Gerrard to talk about himself, and Gerrard feels he has finally found someone to listen to him, albeit under duress.
(iii) Gerrard speaks this line sarcastically. He is not genuinely pleased to have an audience; rather, he is using irony to comment on his dangerous situation.
Question 2
The intruder chooses Gerrard because he notices that Gerrard looks very much like him. This physical resemblance is crucial for his plan to impersonate Gerrard and escape the police, who are hunting him for a murder he has committed.
Question 3
(i) Gerrard says this line.
(ii) This statement implies that when Gerrard found himself in a difficult or dangerous situation in the past, he resorted to using a gun (bullets) to defend himself or to escape.
(iii) No, this is not the truth. Gerrard is fabricating this story as part of his plan to mislead the intruder. He says this to make the intruder believe that he, too, is a dangerous criminal, hoping this will deter the intruder or make him more cautious.
Question 4
Gerrard is a playwright by profession. Several lines from the play support this:
- Gerrard remarks, "This is all very melodramatic, not very original, perhaps, but..."
- He also says, "In most melodramas the villain is foolish enough to delay his killing long enough to be frustrated."
- He refers to the intruder's actions as, "I said, you were luckier than most melodramatic villains."
- Gerrard's comment about props, "That's a disguise outfit; false moustaches and what not," and his intention to use the current events in his work, "I think I'll put it in my next play," further indicate his profession.
Question 5
(i) The intruder says this line to Gerrard.
(ii) The speaker says this to intimidate Gerrard and to assert his dominance. He wants to frighten Gerrard into submission by implying that Gerrard's cleverness will be useless in the face of what is about to happen.
(iii) According to the intruder, Gerrard will stop being smart once he realizes the gravity of his situation – that the intruder intends to kill him and take his identity. The intruder believes that facing his own death will make Gerrard stop being 'smart' and become fearful.
Question 6
(i) The intruder says this line.
(ii) The intruder says this to justify his intention to murder Gerrard. He has already confessed to murdering one person. He explains to Gerrard that since he has already committed a murder, the police cannot hang him again even if he commits another murder.
Question 7
The mystery Gerrard proposes to explain is the fabricated story he invents to deceive the intruder and save his own life. He claims that he himself is a criminal on the run. He explains that his reclusive lifestyle (not meeting tradespeople, being a 'mystery man') is because he is hiding from the law after committing a murder. He also adds that he was expecting trouble and had packed his bags, ready to escape, which is why he appears mysterious.
Question 8
(i) This line is spoken twice in the play. First, it is said by the intruder when he reveals his plan to kill Gerrard and assume his identity. Second, Gerrard says it before he reveals his own fabricated identity to the intruder.
(ii) The surprise refers to different things for each speaker. For the intruder, the surprise is his plan to murder Gerrard and take over his life to live securely. For Gerrard, the surprise is the elaborate, false identity he has concocted as a criminal, which he uses as a weapon against the intruder.
Question 1 (Thinking about the Language)
- The site of the accident was ghastly.
- Our college principal is very strict.
- I studied continuously for eight hours.
- The fog had an adverse effect on the traffic.
- Cezanne, the famous French painter, was a brilliant artist.
- The book that you gave me yesterday is an extraordinary collage of science fiction and mystery.
- Our school will host an exhibition on cruelty to animals and wildlife conservation.
Common mistakes
- Misinterpreting the characters' true intentions.
- Confusing the meanings of similar-sounding words (homophones).
- Failing to grasp the sarcastic or serious tone of dialogues.
- Overlooking the significance of Gerrard's cleverness in manipulating the intruder.
Revision tips
- Reread the play 'If I Were You' to better understand the context of each question.
- Focus on the motivations of both Gerrard and the intruder when answering comprehension questions.
- Pay close attention to the 'Thinking about the Language' section to reinforce vocabulary.
- Practice explaining the plot twists and character strategies in your own words.
Practice MCQs
Q1. Who says the line, 'At last a sympathetic audience.'?
Explanation: Gerrard utters this line sarcastically when the intruder forces him to speak about himself, implying the intruder is his only listener.
Q2. Why does the intruder want to take on Gerrard's identity?
Explanation: The intruder is a murderer on the run and plans to kill Gerrard and assume his identity to evade capture by the police.
Q3. What does Gerrard mean when he says, 'I said it with bullets.'?
Explanation: Gerrard is fabricating a story to mislead the intruder, implying he has a history of violence and self-defense using a firearm.
Q4. Which of the following professions is Gerrard implied to have?
Explanation: Gerrard's dialogue about melodrama, props, and putting events into his next play strongly suggests he is a playwright.
Q5. What is the 'surprise' Gerrard mentions at the end of the play?
Explanation: Gerrard's surprise is the elaborate false identity he has created as a criminal himself, which he uses to outwit the intruder.
Frequently asked questions
What is the main theme of Chapter 20, 'If I Were You'?
The main theme revolves around wit versus brute force, where Gerrard's intelligence and quick thinking outsmart the intruder's violent intentions.
Who are the main characters in 'If I Were You'?
The main characters are Gerrard, a playwright, and an unknown Intruder who plans to murder Gerrard and take his identity.
Why is Gerrard's profession as a playwright important to the plot?
Gerrard's profession allows him to be a convincing storyteller. His knowledge of melodrama and dialogue helps him create a believable false identity to deceive the intruder.
How does Gerrard handle the threat from the intruder?
Gerrard handles the threat by pretending to be a criminal himself, creating a fabricated story about his own life to confuse and trap the intruder.
What is the significance of the line 'They can't hang me twice.'?
This line reveals the intruder's past crime (murder) and his desperate justification for committing another murder, as he believes the law cannot punish him twice for the same crime.
How do these NCERT Solutions help Class 9 students?
These solutions provide clear explanations for comprehension questions, help in understanding character motivations, and reinforce vocabulary, making exam preparation more effective.
Content reviewed by the NCERT Help team. Editorial Team and update policy
NCERT Solutions PDF PDF on NCERT Help. URL unchanged for search indexing.